What is a living will in Ontario?
Living wills and advance care planning in Ontario: healthcare wishes, consent, and powers of attorney for personal care.
Published Last reviewed
People often use the phrase living will to mean written instructions about the care they would want if they could no longer make a decision themselves.
In Ontario, that phrase can be misleading because it blends together two different things: expressing wishes about future care and legally appointing someone to make decisions for you.
A written statement of wishes is therefore not the same thing as a power of attorney for personal care.
What does a living will mean?
A living will usually means a written statement about the care or treatment someone would prefer if they were unable to make a particular decision themselves.
A person might want to express feelings about life-sustaining treatment, comfort, personal dignity, or where and how care should be provided.
Ontario's Health Care Consent Act allows a capable person to express wishes about treatment, admission to a care facility, or personal assistance services. Those wishes may be communicated in writing, orally, or in another manner.
This means there isn't one document title that makes someone's wishes recognizable under Ontario law.
What matters is who expressed the wish, whether they were capable when they did so, what they said, and whether it applies to the decision being made.
Is a living will legally binding?
Whether a wish is binding depends on the wish and the circumstances, not on whether a document is labelled living will. Ontario's public seniors' guide explains that such a document may not be legally binding in every situation and does not appoint a decision-maker. However, an applicable prior wish can have a specific legal effect under the Health Care Consent Act.
For a treatment decision, section 21 of Ontario's Health Care Consent Act generally requires a substitute decision-maker to follow a known wish that applies to the circumstances if it was expressed while the person was capable and after the person reached age 16. If there is no known applicable wish, or if compliance is impossible, the substitute decision-maker must decide according to the best-interests factors set out in the Act.
There can be difficult questions about what a previous statement meant or whether it applies to a new medical situation. Section 5 of the Act provides that later wishes expressed while capable prevail over earlier wishes. A healthcare professional or the Consent and Capacity Board may be involved when disputes or uncertainty arise.
Rather than trying to predict every treatment decision, consider explaining the values and concerns behind your preferences. A conversation with the person who might be asked to decide can be as important as the written record.
Who makes decisions if you cannot?
When someone is capable of making a particular treatment decision, it is generally their decision to give or refuse informed consent.
If they are found incapable of making that decision, Ontario law identifies who may act as their substitute decision-maker. The person might be an attorney for personal care, a guardian, or someone in a statutory family hierarchy, depending on the situation.
You cannot assume that being married or being a close relative gives someone authority in every possible decision. The relevant legal rules and the person's existing appointments matter.
If there are competing relatives or questions about authority, the healthcare team or a qualified legal professional can explain the applicable process.
How is a power of attorney for personal care different?
A power of attorney for personal care is a legal document through which someone appoints an attorney to make certain personal-care decisions when legally authorized to do so. In Ontario, the person making this appointment must generally be at least 16 years old and meet the applicable capacity requirements; executing a valid document involves specific formalities.
Despite the name, that attorney doesn't have to be a lawyer. They might be a spouse, relative, friend or another person who is legally eligible and willing to take the role.
Ontario's personal-care power of attorney can cover decisions about health care, shelter, nutrition, hygiene and other aspects of care within the scope of the law and document.
The appointment and the person's wishes work together but are not identical. A written statement of wishes does not itself appoint an attorney for personal care.
Ontario also has a different document called a continuing power of attorney for property, which relates to financial affairs. The person making this type of appointment must generally be at least 18. Someone might have both documents, naming the same or different people.
For a fuller overview of the planning options, see What is a will in Ontario?. A will takes effect on death, whereas powers of attorney concern decisions during life.
Do you have to put your wishes in writing?
No. Ontario law can recognize wishes expressed in other ways by a capable person. The Health Care Consent Act recognizes wishes expressed orally and in other ways by a capable person.
Writing down preferences can nevertheless make it easier to share them accurately, especially if several people might be involved. A document may also help those close to you understand the values behind your decisions.
Tell the appropriate people that you've made the record and how to find it. Consider discussing it with your healthcare professional, particularly if the wishes relate to a medical condition or a treatment whose likely consequences you want to understand.
If you later change your mind while capable, communicate that change. An old document that no longer reflects your wishes can create confusion.
What should you think about before making plans?
It may help to distinguish three questions:
- What matters to me in the way I receive care?
- Who could speak on my behalf if I couldn't make a particular decision?
- How would that person know what I wanted?
You may want to discuss how your preferences relate to a serious illness, comfort-oriented care, hospital treatment, or cultural or religious practices. Avoid assuming a short checklist can cover every situation.
A lawyer can help with appointing a decision-maker and understanding the legal form. A healthcare professional can explain treatment options and the medical questions involved.
Planning is less about predicting exactly what will happen than about making it easier for the right people to understand and respect your choices.
Sources and further information
Government of Ontario
Explains property and personal-care powers of attorney, and the role of expressed healthcare wishes.
Ontario e-Laws
Sections 5 and 20–21 address capable wishes and substitute decision-making for treatment. Applicability and the in-force text must be checked.
Ontario e-Laws
Substitute Decisions Act, 1992
Addresses the power of attorney for personal care and continuing powers of attorney for property.
Government of Ontario
Guide to programs and services for seniors — law and legal matters
Includes a short explanation of the term living will and cautions about its legal effect.